Not every game deserves the lofty acclaim it receives, right?

If we really stop to think about it, we can all come up with a few titles that we think got some super high scores it just didn't quite deserve. What were a few for you so far this generation?

And bear in mind that I'm asking about "overrated" as opposed to "under-appreciated." In my eyes, the latter term is more about sales while the former is about critical acclaim. There's a definite difference, of course. Personally, I'm not sure which game would sit atop my "most overrated" list right now, though I do think some critics go a little too crazy with the Dark Souls games. Sometimes I think they're so desparate to have a true "hardcore" game that they're willing to overlook every conceivable flaw. I've also never really understood the constant fawning over any new Mario game. For crying out loud, they're not that good, especially not when compared to, you know, modern productions.

What games might be on your list? I know many thought Dragon Age: Inquisition didn't really deserve the extremely high scores it got from a lot of sources, and there are those who say too many critics once again willfully overlooked the flaws in Grand Theft Auto V (reviewers heard similar accusations with GTAIV). Then there are those who don't believe last year's Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain was worthy of the scores it got, saying the game was simply too much of a departure from what made the franchise great in the first place.

What do you think?

Subscribe
Notify of
46 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
InBlackestNight
InBlackestNight
4 years ago

I'd have to say Call of Duty. They really haven't changed much at all. Very repetitive and less and less story every year.

FM23
FM23
4 years ago

People love to hate GTA because it's so popular. Dark Souls is full of flaws, but it's so unique and good at what it does that it's hard to fault it. I'm mean if you're a fan of course.

I can't think of an overrated game this generation because everything has been fairly rated. Not too many highly rated games. Even MGSV to me earned that 9+ rating. I have played all MGS' s and this one was way better than the others even if the story wasn't as engulfing.

If I had to choose though…Destiny! And maybe DAI for its default GOTY awards during one of the most disastrous yrs of gaming (2014). I did enjoy DAI though.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
4 years ago

Inquisition is a big overrated game. They stripped the story and crew time down to just a handful of moments and gave us a bunch of empty maps and little fetch quests instead.

Hexen
Hexen
4 years ago

Inquisition was such a boring piece of garbage, I had more fun looking at the ps4 turned off.

Draguss
Draguss
4 years ago

Ask me again after uncharted 4 is released.

shadowpal2
shadowpal2
4 years ago

Phantom Pain for me is overrated dare I say it as a long time Metal Gear fan.

The graphics were great, gameplay was fantastic/fluid/excellent, OST was gorgeous even if not done by Harry Gregson Williams, but what was lackluster was the overall story.

There were some well directed moments in the game which hit close to the heart of a Metal Gear fan – but the overall story was just all over the place – quite repetitive and simply not as exciting/epic as some of the other stories in the series have been. The ending was flat out silly – and not shocking since I called it…2.5 years back. The story wasn't just lackluster because it was left "unfinished" – although that certainly was quite unfortunate and not Kojima's fault.

But still…it really had a phantom plot as some others have been saying.

It was an MGS which divided the fan base imo.

tlpn99
tlpn99
4 years ago

This is exactly how I feel about MGS The Phantom pain.

Smooth nice looking game just bored me. I stopped playing it. Too much like Peace Walker for me. I liked Ground Zeroes though.

Other games I'd say was/is Destiny and Final Fantasy just never did it for me either. Also Star Wars Battlefront. Infamous First Light. Didn't like the new Cole. Or the new Devil May Cry. Been a good few so far.

To this list I'm going to add the new Ratchet And Clank game. Didn't like them back in the day. Too much happening on the screen at once.


Last edited by tlpn99 on 3/24/2016 2:48:00 AM

Bio
Bio
4 years ago

Nobody "called" that ending years ago.

slow and smart
slow and smart
4 years ago

Yep,MGS the phantom pain

cadpig
cadpig
4 years ago

The Division and Star Wars Battlefront are my picks for most overrated games.

Hexen
Hexen
4 years ago

Anything with Mario or anything from Ubisoft.

bigrailer19
bigrailer19
4 years ago

Battlefront probably if I'm being honest. But DA:I is a close runner up.

frostface
frostface
4 years ago

I disagree with Dark Soul's being glitchy but when people get frustrated because they can't play the game, whether due to lack of skill or they just haven't figured thing's out yet, I get why it would make their overrated list.

DA Inquisition is on my list, as are the MGS games. Also didn't get into the last infamous game. It just didn't grab me.

xenris
xenris
4 years ago

I agree, there arent many objective flaws in the Souls games aside from glitches and bugs that slip through the cracks. I think it is more people not knowing how to play them or change how they typically approach a game.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
4 years ago

The last inFamous was for toddlers or somethin

TrueAssassin86x
TrueAssassin86x
4 years ago

– The Witcher 3 those i enjoy the game its Overrated.
– Bloodborn is another.
And last but not least any of the indies

xenris
xenris
4 years ago

MGS5 was the first MGS game I didn't finish, not to mention I finished every other MGS game multiple times.

It felt off in the places I needed it to be on. Story was off, pacing was off because of the open world, which felt dead and lifeless to me.

On a pure gameplay side of things it was the best of all of them, controls were amazing, graphics are stellar and the variety of ways you COULD approach things was high. But it felt hollow to me, and the story which is why fell in love with the franchise in the first place was pretty much absent.

As for the souls games I would just like to point out that the games are pain stakingly hand crafted by Miyazaki(DS2 aside)and he has probably the best grasp in the industry of proper level design.

Item placement in areas alone gives you hints both on the lore and on what to expect for the upcoming area and boss fights. Whether one can see it or not is another story, but the game ALWAYS gives you exactly what you need to overcome its challenges.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
4 years ago

Witcher 3. Generic with high production values.

Or anything with Dark Souls attached. Hard doesn't mean good.

JackieBoy
JackieBoy
4 years ago

MGS5 hands down

Vivi_Gamer
Vivi_Gamer
4 years ago

UnderTale… I'm sick of hearing about it. That or Gone Home, one fo the dullest experiences I have ever had.

The Phantom Pain was broken, but still had a lot to offer in the gaemplay department… I still can't forgive how they handled the narrative though, recent replayed it to for the Platinum… my dissapointment remains 🙁

AMERICANSHEEPLE
AMERICANSHEEPLE
4 years ago

Any one of the last 3 Assassins Creed, & Dishonored! Wayyyyyyyyyyy overrated!

Godslim
Godslim
4 years ago

mgs5 for the same reasons shadowpal stated above!
Although swbf too!

Jumpinbeans
Jumpinbeans
4 years ago

GTA5 – couldn't stand it

Vivi_Gamer
Vivi_Gamer
4 years ago

UnderTale… I&#39m sick of hearing about it. That or Gone Home, one fo the dullest experiences I have ever had.

The Phantom Pain was broken, but still had a lot to offer in the gaemplay department… I still can&#39t forgive how they handled the narrative though, recent replayed it to for the Platinum… my dissapointment remains 🙁

JackieBoy
JackieBoy
4 years ago

MGS5 hands down

AMERICANSHEEPLE
AMERICANSHEEPLE
4 years ago

Any one of the last 3 Assassins Creed, & Dishonored! Wayyyyyyyyyyy overrated!

Godslim
Godslim
4 years ago

mgs5 for the same reasons shadowpal stated above!
Although swbf too!

Jumpinbeans
Jumpinbeans
4 years ago

GTA5 – couldn&#39t stand it

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
4 years ago

Inquisition is a big overrated game. They stripped the story and crew time down to just a handful of moments and gave us a bunch of empty maps and little fetch quests instead.

Bio
Bio
4 years ago

Nobody "called" that ending years ago.

InBlackestNight
InBlackestNight
4 years ago

I&#39d have to say Call of Duty. They really haven&#39t changed much at all. Very repetitive and less and less story every year.

FM23
FM23
4 years ago

People love to hate GTA because it&#39s so popular. Dark Souls is full of flaws, but it&#39s so unique and good at what it does that it&#39s hard to fault it. I&#39m mean if you&#39re a fan of course.

I can&#39t think of an overrated game this generation because everything has been fairly rated. Not too many highly rated games. Even MGSV to me earned that 9+ rating. I have played all MGS&#39 s and this one was way better than the others even if the story wasn&#39t as engulfing.

If I had to choose though…Destiny! And maybe DAI for its default GOTY awards during one of the most disastrous yrs of gaming (2014). I did enjoy DAI though.

Hexen
Hexen
4 years ago

Inquisition was such a boring piece of garbage, I had more fun looking at the ps4 turned off.

shadowpal2
shadowpal2
4 years ago

Phantom Pain for me is overrated dare I say it as a long time Metal Gear fan.

The graphics were great, gameplay was fantastic/fluid/excellent, OST was gorgeous even if not done by Harry Gregson Williams, but what was lackluster was the overall story.

There were some well directed moments in the game which hit close to the heart of a Metal Gear fan – but the overall story was just all over the place – quite repetitive and simply not as exciting/epic as some of the other stories in the series have been. The ending was flat out silly – and not shocking since I called it…2.5 years back. The story wasn&#39t just lackluster because it was left "unfinished" – although that certainly was quite unfortunate and not Kojima&#39s fault.

But still…it really had a phantom plot as some others have been saying.

It was an MGS which divided the fan base imo.

slow and smart
slow and smart
4 years ago

Yep,MGS the phantom pain

Draguss
Draguss
4 years ago

Ask me again after uncharted 4 is released.

cadpig
cadpig
4 years ago

The Division and Star Wars Battlefront are my picks for most overrated games.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
4 years ago

Witcher 3. Generic with high production values.

Or anything with Dark Souls attached. Hard doesn&#39t mean good.

frostface
frostface
4 years ago

I disagree with Dark Soul&#39s being glitchy but when people get frustrated because they can&#39t play the game, whether due to lack of skill or they just haven&#39t figured thing&#39s out yet, I get why it would make their overrated list.

DA Inquisition is on my list, as are the MGS games. Also didn&#39t get into the last infamous game. It just didn&#39t grab me.

Hexen
Hexen
4 years ago

Anything with Mario or anything from Ubisoft.

tlpn99
tlpn99
4 years ago

This is exactly how I feel about MGS The Phantom pain.

Smooth nice looking game just bored me. I stopped playing it. Too much like Peace Walker for me. I liked Ground Zeroes though.

Other games I&#39d say was/is Destiny and Final Fantasy just never did it for me either. Also Star Wars Battlefront. Infamous First Light. Didn&#39t like the new Cole. Or the new Devil May Cry. Been a good few so far.

To this list I&#39m going to add the new Ratchet And Clank game. Didn&#39t like them back in the day. Too much happening on the screen at once.


Last edited by tlpn99 on 3/24/2016 2:48:00 AM

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
4 years ago

The last inFamous was for toddlers or somethin

xenris
xenris
4 years ago

MGS5 was the first MGS game I didn&#39t finish, not to mention I finished every other MGS game multiple times.

It felt off in the places I needed it to be on. Story was off, pacing was off because of the open world, which felt dead and lifeless to me.

On a pure gameplay side of things it was the best of all of them, controls were amazing, graphics are stellar and the variety of ways you COULD approach things was high. But it felt hollow to me, and the story which is why fell in love with the franchise in the first place was pretty much absent.

As for the souls games I would just like to point out that the games are pain stakingly hand crafted by Miyazaki(DS2 aside)and he has probably the best grasp in the industry of proper level design.

Item placement in areas alone gives you hints both on the lore and on what to expect for the upcoming area and boss fights. Whether one can see it or not is another story, but the game ALWAYS gives you exactly what you need to overcome its challenges.

xenris
xenris
4 years ago

I agree, there arent many objective flaws in the Souls games aside from glitches and bugs that slip through the cracks. I think it is more people not knowing how to play them or change how they typically approach a game.

bigrailer19
bigrailer19
4 years ago

Battlefront probably if I&#39m being honest. But DA:I is a close runner up.

TrueAssassin86x
TrueAssassin86x
4 years ago

– The Witcher 3 those i enjoy the game its Overrated.
– Bloodborn is another.
And last but not least any of the indies