Many are saying it's the hands-down winner, and they're convinced no other game – even ones that aren't out yet – will be able to touch Kojima's latest masterpiece in the 2015 Game of the Year race.

But is that really true?

Well, so far, from a statistical standpoint, it is. Currently, Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain holds a 95 average at Metacritic, the highest average for any game this year (not counting remasters, HD upgrades, and various re-releases). Only Bloodborne and The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt are close, as both hold a 92 average.

At this point, many would put Batman: Arkham Knight in the running as well. Looking down the road, perhaps the only game capable of going toe-to-toe with MGSV is the hotly anticipated Fallout 4 ; historically, this series has scored off the charts (with the exception of the merely average Fallout: New Vegas ). Other big titles include Assassin's Creed Syndicate , Star Wars: Battlefront , Mad Max , Call of Duty: Black Ops III , Need for Speed and Just Cause 3 . But it's unlikely that any will score in the mid-90s.

But here's the more interesting question: In your mind, which will be most deserving of the best overall game of 2015? Will it indeed be MGSV? Or will you retain a very soft spot for the likes of Bloodborne , The Witcher 3 and Batman ? Can we really say the new MGS has this prestigious award all locked up?

Related Game(s): Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Subscribe
Notify of
54 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Draguss
Draguss
6 years ago

Witcher 3 and Fallout 4 will probably be its main competition. Arkham Knight doesn't deserve it. It's a great game in theory, but between the misleading marketing because their grand mystery was obvious to every batman fan on the planet, and the absolutely shameful pc port, it really doesn't deserve to be considered, in my opinion.

souljah92
souljah92
6 years ago

I Am Bread goty, gtfo

JonnyR
JonnyR
6 years ago

depending on how it turns out upon its release, i think fallout 4 could have the edge in terms of what would be MGSV's main competition.

Also 5 days to go people!!!

PoopsMcGee
PoopsMcGee
6 years ago

Once I play MGSV I'm sure it will make me reconsider, but I have to go with Bloodborne. And I really don't think anything will top that experience for me this year, even considering how awesome this year is turning out.

Fallout 4 could end up making it a three-way race for me, personally. We'll see…


Last edited by PoopsMcGee on 8/26/2015 10:35:37 PM

PoopsMcGee
PoopsMcGee
6 years ago

Oh, and I spaced out completely on Persona 5! I know it's a somewhat niche title for the mainstream sites to pick (especially in a year with as much quality as this one), but for my personal GOY it will most definitely be in the running…

souljah92
souljah92
6 years ago

I love your name

Temjin001
Temjin001
6 years ago

I look forward to Kojima taking top honors, slaying 'next-gen' experiences like Batman, Bloodborne, Witcher, Fall Out, and Devil's Third with a cross-gen game.


Last edited by Temjin001 on 8/26/2015 10:39:22 PM

Jawknee
Jawknee
6 years ago

*high five*

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
6 years ago

Konami will rue the day they pissed off the master

bigrailer19
bigrailer19
6 years ago

Fallout 4 will get the majority of GOTY votes from the media, I'm almost certain. Unless of course it turns out terrible (very unlikely). I imagine MGS will get a considerable amount of GOTY winnings as well. At this point there's not just one GOTY winner because every gaming media outlet has one.

Jalex
Jalex
6 years ago

'Fallout 4' is definitely going to give it the most competition, but the reviews for 'The Phantom Pain' so far make it seem like topping that will be difficult for any game. 'Fallout' has more mainstream appeal, but 'Metal Gear' is (historically) far more technically proficient than the former.


Last edited by Jalex on 8/26/2015 11:24:43 PM

Corvo
Corvo
6 years ago

Fallout 4 is going to win. I don't know why this is even a question.

Dishonored Definitive is my GOTY though. Well…crap. Bloodborne. Whatever. Until Dawn is great too.

Vivi_Gamer
Vivi_Gamer
6 years ago

Nothing for me. However after a very drab year for releases it looks like it's finally getting interesting. Beyond The Phantom Pain you have. Fallout 4, Until Dawn and Star Wars Battlefront . All games interest me and I'll be picking the up (apart from Fallout 4 as I'm waiting for the DLC edition next year). But nothing will surpass The Phantom Pain, it's going to be such an experience… Gosh only 4 days now 🙂


Last edited by Vivi_Gamer on 8/27/2015 2:42:25 AM

trumpetmon65
trumpetmon65
6 years ago

I just think they're all winners, Ben. Seriously though, if Fallout doesn't beat it, I don't know what will.

Godslim
Godslim
6 years ago

fallout 4 or star wars battlefront maybe

TrueAssassin86x
TrueAssassin86x
6 years ago

For me its a battle between Metal Gear Solid 5, Witcher 3, Bloodborn, Batman Arkham Knight, Until Dawn, and Yet to be release Rise of the Tomb Raider and Halo 5, yes i know this is a PlayStation site still dont sleep on either game

Rachet_JC_FTW
Rachet_JC_FTW
6 years ago

i have to say my first thought was fallout 4 but bloodbourne, the witch 3 and batman i think will probably be close between them.

and to a lesser extent Assassin's Creed Syndicate, Star Wars: Battlefront, Mad Max, and Just Cause 3.

Call of Duty: Black Ops III, Need for Speed are really not contenders to me they are prestigise enough for GOTY no affense they came out all the time, yeah i like AC better personally if haven't read between lines already.

you really want one of those games that comes out one every so often hence why i say fallout 4 but bloodbourne, the witch 3 and batman will be the front runners so far.

thats my 2 cents on GOTY centenders thus far.

happy gaming


Last edited by Rachet_JC_FTW on 8/27/2015 7:11:00 AM

xenris
xenris
6 years ago

The Order is obviously getting game of the year guys :P(just trolling but I did love The Order)

I think it is kind of unfair most GotY games that release closer to the end of the year get picked because they are the most recently played.

However, I think that Bloodborne, the Witcher 3 and Fallout 4 and MGS5 are all great contenders even though we haven't played FO4 yet.

My personal GotY is Bloodborne, everyone here knows I have a dirty soft spot for these games. But on top of that it's level design, and pacing are just so fantastic. I think it deserves it because while it has elements of souls games it is the only title in that list that is technically a new IP.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
6 years ago

Goat Simulator for sure.

TrueAssassin86x
TrueAssassin86x
6 years ago

Lol sony failboys giving me a thumbs down thats ok dont be crying when Rise of The Tomb Raider or Halo 5 wins

Legendary Minja
Legendary Minja
6 years ago

Dude you got 1 thumb down, calm yourself. It's not a popularity contest lol.

SayWord
SayWord
6 years ago

You have issues…

pillz81
pillz81
6 years ago

Wow, if you're responding to one thumb down, you are just butthurt.
If it makes you feel better, I just thumbed you up.


Last edited by pillz81 on 8/27/2015 12:40:29 PM

souljah92
souljah92
6 years ago

Being a cornhole gets you thumbed down

Legendary Minja
Legendary Minja
6 years ago

Spike TV will probably award GOTY to Evolve or something lol.

I will go with Phantom Pain this year even though I love my Witcher 3 and Bloodborne.

slow and smart
slow and smart
6 years ago

until now i would say MGS V but Fallout 4 could also be the GOTY….

Off topic:i play'd The vanishing of Ethan Carter twice and both times i suffered from motion sickness,i changed some settings[crosshair/motion blur/FOV ]and stil motion sickness,man….i never had this with a game before and i know that i'm not the only one[google] …..maybe because of the low view i don't know.
Can anybody give me some info about"everybody's gone to the rapture" ,has this game also a low view?


Last edited by slow and smart on 8/27/2015 12:02:53 PM

Kevin555
Kevin555
6 years ago

Until Dawn should win sleeper hit of the year imo.

as for game of the year, my money is on either MGSV or Fallout 4.

Legendary Minja
Legendary Minja
2 years ago

Spike TV will probably award GOTY to Evolve or something lol.

I will go with Phantom Pain this year even though I love my Witcher 3 and Bloodborne.

slow and smart
slow and smart
2 years ago

until now i would say MGS V but Fallout 4 could also be the GOTY….

Off topic:i play&#39d The vanishing of Ethan Carter twice and both times i suffered from motion sickness,i changed some settings[crosshair/motion blur/FOV ]and stil motion sickness,man….i never had this with a game before and i know that i&#39m not the only one[google] …..maybe because of the low view i don&#39t know.
Can anybody give me some info about"everybody&#39s gone to the rapture" ,has this game also a low view?

Last edited by slow and smart on 8/27/2015 12:02:53 PM

Jawknee
Jawknee
2 years ago

*high five*

PoopsMcGee
PoopsMcGee
2 years ago

Oh, and I spaced out completely on Persona 5! I know it&#39s a somewhat niche title for the mainstream sites to pick (especially in a year with as much quality as this one), but for my personal GOY it will most definitely be in the running…

souljah92
souljah92
2 years ago

I Am Bread goty, gtfo

souljah92
souljah92
2 years ago

I love your name

Corvo
Corvo
2 years ago

Fallout 4 is going to win. I don&#39t know why this is even a question.

Dishonored Definitive is my GOTY though. Well…crap. Bloodborne. Whatever. Until Dawn is great too.

PoopsMcGee
PoopsMcGee
2 years ago

Once I play MGSV I&#39m sure it will make me reconsider, but I have to go with Bloodborne. And I really don&#39t think anything will top that experience for me this year, even considering how awesome this year is turning out.

Fallout 4 could end up making it a three-way race for me, personally. We&#39ll see…

Last edited by PoopsMcGee on 8/26/2015 10:35:37 PM

JonnyR
JonnyR
2 years ago

depending on how it turns out upon its release, i think fallout 4 could have the edge in terms of what would be MGSV&#39s main competition.

Also 5 days to go people!!!

Temjin001
Temjin001
2 years ago

I look forward to Kojima taking top honors, slaying &#39next-gen&#39 experiences like Batman, Bloodborne, Witcher, Fall Out, and Devil&#39s Third with a cross-gen game.

Last edited by Temjin001 on 8/26/2015 10:39:22 PM

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
2 years ago

Konami will rue the day they pissed off the master

Jalex
Jalex
2 years ago

&#39Fallout 4&#39 is definitely going to give it the most competition, but the reviews for &#39The Phantom Pain&#39 so far make it seem like topping that will be difficult for any game. &#39Fallout&#39 has more mainstream appeal, but &#39Metal Gear&#39 is (historically) far more technically proficient than the former.

Last edited by Jalex on 8/26/2015 11:24:43 PM

bigrailer19
bigrailer19
2 years ago

Fallout 4 will get the majority of GOTY votes from the media, I&#39m almost certain. Unless of course it turns out terrible (very unlikely). I imagine MGS will get a considerable amount of GOTY winnings as well. At this point there&#39s not just one GOTY winner because every gaming media outlet has one.

trumpetmon65
trumpetmon65
2 years ago

I just think they&#39re all winners, Ben. Seriously though, if Fallout doesn&#39t beat it, I don&#39t know what will.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
2 years ago

Goat Simulator for sure.

Draguss
Draguss
2 years ago

Witcher 3 and Fallout 4 will probably be its main competition. Arkham Knight doesn&#39t deserve it. It&#39s a great game in theory, but between the misleading marketing because their grand mystery was obvious to every batman fan on the planet, and the absolutely shameful pc port, it really doesn&#39t deserve to be considered, in my opinion.

TrueAssassin86x
TrueAssassin86x
2 years ago

For me its a battle between Metal Gear Solid 5, Witcher 3, Bloodborn, Batman Arkham Knight, Until Dawn, and Yet to be release Rise of the Tomb Raider and Halo 5, yes i know this is a PlayStation site still dont sleep on either game

Legendary Minja
Legendary Minja
2 years ago

Dude you got 1 thumb down, calm yourself. It&#39s not a popularity contest lol.

SayWord
SayWord
2 years ago

You have issues…

xenris
xenris
2 years ago

The Order is obviously getting game of the year guys :P(just trolling but I did love The Order)

I think it is kind of unfair most GotY games that release closer to the end of the year get picked because they are the most recently played.

However, I think that Bloodborne, the Witcher 3 and Fallout 4 and MGS5 are all great contenders even though we haven&#39t played FO4 yet.

My personal GotY is Bloodborne, everyone here knows I have a dirty soft spot for these games. But on top of that it&#39s level design, and pacing are just so fantastic. I think it deserves it because while it has elements of souls games it is the only title in that list that is technically a new IP.

TrueAssassin86x
TrueAssassin86x
2 years ago

Lol sony failboys giving me a thumbs down thats ok dont be crying when Rise of The Tomb Raider or Halo 5 wins

Godslim
Godslim
2 years ago

fallout 4 or star wars battlefront maybe

souljah92
souljah92
2 years ago

Being a cornhole gets you thumbed down

New Report

Close