Ever since they announced Shenmue 3 and the Final Fantasy VII Remake at E3, I've been wondering:

Is there any chance these new incarnations can attract the younger generation? In other words, will either game appeal to anybody who is unfamiliar? If you never played the original games, what are the chances that you're going to care?

I guess there's a slim chance. Square Enix has already said the FFVII remake won't be the same game , which probably means they're planning some real-time action-oriented mess that doesn't even remotely resemble an RPG. But whatever. It's what they do. As for Yu Suzuki and Co., I think they might produce something that's closer to the original game(s); it might be better that it didn't hit the $10 million goal, actually.

If Square Enix wrecks FFVII, nobody will want it. The fans will just ignore it and try to pretend it doesn't exist, while newcomers will only see "Final Fantasy" in the title and likely be scared off. If you want the action crowd, it's hard to convince them to buy a franchise they've always associated with role-playing, no matter how flashy and bombastic you can make it. As for Shenmue 3 , I have a bad feeling it can only be effectively marketed towards Japanese gamers. Young American gamers will only see "some old Japanese game" they don't care about.

But who knows, right?

Related Game(s): Final Fantasy VII Remake, Shenmue 3

Subscribe
Notify of
16 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
JackieBoy
JackieBoy
6 years ago

I haven't played previous Shenmue's and I won't be playing this one either – just not my thing, so the answer is "no".

"If Square Enix wrecks FFVII, nobody will want it. The fans will just ignore it and try to pretend it doesn't exist…"
I'm sold on FF7 whatever the outcome will be.
So you are WRONG.
AGAIN.

Banky A
Banky A
6 years ago

Haha if SE wrecks FFVII, I'll want it even more.

Will get the collectors edition and it will sit proudly on any display.

trumpetmon65
trumpetmon65
6 years ago

I'm sure they will attract new fans and repulse some old ones, because gamers

Vivi_Gamer
Vivi_Gamer
6 years ago

I don't know… the problem is that there is still not option of getting a HD remaster of Shenmue 1 & 2. I think that is still vital to the release of Shenmue 3. So ppeople can gather an understanding of just how much of a step forward the game was – While we have sandbox titles today, Shenmues environments feel alive, with the active time system set to calander dates. But at the heart of Shenmue is a compelling story of a man seekign vengeance and what it will lead to we will have to wait and see 🙂

As for Final Fantasy VII… I can't tell, this will be very different to the original, think of it almost as an adaptation in up to date technology rather than a piece by piece remake. Different battel system, no world map, voice acting you may not like. It's going to be a tough journey, but one I am still encouraged by.

Underdog15
Underdog15
6 years ago

Definitely. I, for one, had completely missed what Shenmue was before all this. If I get into it, then that's one new fan right there! lol

FFVII will attract new fans because it's a legend in gaming. Even those who never touched it have heard of it. And it's story is alluring as well. It's not exactly Shakespeare, but it has all the key components of Melodrama. And people are suckers for textbook fantasy melodrama… just look at Star Wars.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
6 years ago

Get a Dreamcast!

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
6 years ago

If FFVII is turn based at its core (ya know despite whatever new bells and whistles exist) then you'll see new fans.

People who don't yet know this kind of battle is much more epic, intelligent, strategic, cinematic, and generally more cool than just whacking the bad guy will enjoy and wonder why it wasn't done before.

Rachet_JC_FTW
Rachet_JC_FTW
6 years ago

possibly gamers are gamers if we think a game is worth while we'll go for it i wouldn't be surprised.

happy gaming

Banky A
Banky A
6 years ago

Haha if SE wrecks FFVII, I&#39ll want it even more.

Will get the collectors edition and it will sit proudly on any display.

Underdog15
Underdog15
2 years ago

Definitely. I, for one, had completely missed what Shenmue was before all this. If I get into it, then that&#39s one new fan right there! lol

FFVII will attract new fans because it&#39s a legend in gaming. Even those who never touched it have heard of it. And it&#39s story is alluring as well. It&#39s not exactly Shakespeare, but it has all the key components of Melodrama. And people are suckers for textbook fantasy melodrama… just look at Star Wars.

Rachet_JC_FTW
Rachet_JC_FTW
2 years ago

possibly gamers are gamers if we think a game is worth while we&#39ll go for it i wouldn&#39t be surprised.

happy gaming

Vivi_Gamer
Vivi_Gamer
2 years ago

I don&#39t know… the problem is that there is still not option of getting a HD remaster of Shenmue 1 & 2. I think that is still vital to the release of Shenmue 3. So ppeople can gather an understanding of just how much of a step forward the game was – While we have sandbox titles today, Shenmues environments feel alive, with the active time system set to calander dates. But at the heart of Shenmue is a compelling story of a man seekign vengeance and what it will lead to we will have to wait and see 🙂

As for Final Fantasy VII… I can&#39t tell, this will be very different to the original, think of it almost as an adaptation in up to date technology rather than a piece by piece remake. Different battel system, no world map, voice acting you may not like. It&#39s going to be a tough journey, but one I am still encouraged by.

JackieBoy
JackieBoy
2 years ago

I haven&#39t played previous Shenmue&#39s and I won&#39t be playing this one either – just not my thing, so the answer is "no".

"If Square Enix wrecks FFVII, nobody will want it. The fans will just ignore it and try to pretend it doesn&#39t exist…"
I&#39m sold on FF7 whatever the outcome will be.
So you are WRONG.
AGAIN.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
2 years ago

If FFVII is turn based at its core (ya know despite whatever new bells and whistles exist) then you&#39ll see new fans.

People who don&#39t yet know this kind of battle is much more epic, intelligent, strategic, cinematic, and generally more cool than just whacking the bad guy will enjoy and wonder why it wasn&#39t done before.

trumpetmon65
trumpetmon65
2 years ago

I&#39m sure they will attract new fans and repulse some old ones, because gamers

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
2 years ago

Get a Dreamcast!