This whole thing is shaping up badly.

Consider the evidence, if you will:

Over the past few months, this game has been the center of plenty of controversy. There was that new gameplay footage, which appeared to have been drastically scaled down . We've seen media since that looks fantastic, though, and Ubisoft didn't seem to put much stock in those comparison videos.

Going back further, we've got the delay, which caused plenty of backlash. It's not common for such a huge title to get pushed back so late in the day, and wild theories quickly began to circulate. We remember the situation back in October; many, including analyst Michael Pachter , believed Watch Dogs wouldn't have been able to compete against the heavy hitters. Ubisoft claimed the game simply wasn't ready.

Now, the world's first review has been released: A glowing 19 out of 20 stars from Jeux Video. Yes, that's a French publication and of course, Ubisoft is a French company. As you might expect, there are other factors involved in a world premiere review, as indicated by this article . Furthermore, we're hearing things about the review embargo – and how Ubisoft is hand-picking critics to handle the first round of reviews – and that's not helping, either.

Those who have been reading and ingesting all these headlines might be a little skeptical of reviews, that's all I'm saying.

Related Game(s): Watch Dogs

Subscribe
Notify of
20 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
SASSYGIRL82
SASSYGIRL82
7 years ago

If u have doubt's just go watch the ppl live steaming the game on ps4

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
7 years ago

If they are hand picking who they release it to for the first round of reviews then they deserve all the skepticism they get.

You know a movie is suck when it isn't even screened for the press. Ubi clearly must want trend setting scores with trusted favorability givers (soft critics) before the real ones are given a shot.

If I ever do play it it'll be bargain bin. THIS is the title that seems generic to me.

souljah92
souljah92
7 years ago

In light of Far Cry 4 I am a bit skeptical that you have this white guy running around hacking all of what is sure to be chinaman technology, i demand an apology!

slow and smart
slow and smart
7 years ago

@World:"If I ever do play it it'll be bargain bin. THIS is the title that seems generic to me."
Yep,exactly!

souljah92
souljah92
7 years ago

can't see this title hitting a bargain bin anytime soon man

tes37
tes37
7 years ago

I pre-ordered Watch Dogs after seeing recent videos and reading what people were saying about it.

I watched a few live streams on PS4. The video is not as sharp as the image you'll see when you play it, but you can tell the game looks pretty good.

Corvo
Corvo
7 years ago

There's plenty of footage on youtube, go check it out if you wanna see if its worth the investment.

I haven't watched anything on it yet and probably won't until I play it for myself.

Beamboom
Beamboom
7 years ago

"Ubisoft is hand-picking critics to handle the first round of reviews"

-> That's *exactly* what I've been suspecting all along. Nobody will make me imagine Ubisoft is the only ones practising this.

Those of us who keep an eye on metascore sites recognize this: The first few reviews are very often suspiciously high compared to the reviews who later are published. That is just how it is. And also, typically the first reviews comes from some stray sites that makes you go "wtf, who are those guys!?". And it's not like it's always the same names popping up with early reviews, nope, no pattern there.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
7 years ago

you nailed it, that must be why metacritic scores go that way.

Big_Boss90
Big_Boss90
7 years ago

Really looking foward to this game, might get it day one if all else fails i will continue to enjoy my replay of the entire Arkham series :). Iam so hyped for Arkham Knight.

Swinny
Swinny
7 years ago

When aren't gamers suspicious? That's the question.
Just about any comments section on the internet reveals that gamers are a paranoid bunch, sometimes its called for, most of the time its not.


Last edited by Swinny on 5/26/2014 6:09:49 AM

Nix50
Nix50
7 years ago

I have played the game. There's nothing wrong with the visuals, they're quite nice actually. It does suffer from a few issues which I believe are going to be remedied in a day one patch or something. Driving is a bit wonky and also there is definitely a frame rate issue when driving at really high speeds.

Animestar
Animestar
7 years ago

@SASSYGIRL82, I did what you suggest and it didn't help.

Animestar
Animestar
7 years ago

@SASSYGIRL82, I did what you suggest and it didn't sold me, still having doubts on Watch Dogs,watching the game on PS4 did nothing for me,doesn't look half of fun like GTA 5.

Animestar
Animestar
7 years ago

@Swinny, Can you blame them? how many times are publishers honest with gamers, guess you think it's okay for them to mislead us from time to time…

Underdog15
Underdog15
7 years ago

You should use the reply button.

Swinny
Swinny
7 years ago

No I don't think that's OK, but I also don't think its OK to completely undermine what gaming is all about by becoming a whiny cynic with a paranoia problem.

Temjin001
Temjin001
7 years ago

I don't know what to expect from Watch Dogs. In one hand I think it has goty potential written all over it. On the other hand, it may be a mixed bag for all the various reasons described, including also just not being optimally executed.
The positive thing in my mind is that Ubisoft has a current track history of producing quality games.

ACIV
Rayman Legends
Child of Light
Splinter Cell
FC3

I'm really impressed by how they turned both Assassin's Creed's and Splinter Cell's boat around. I can't think of too many instances where a franchise was sinking in the eyes of critics and then pulled off a recovery.


Last edited by Temjin001 on 5/26/2014 10:32:05 AM

Beamboom
Beamboom
7 years ago

"The positive thing in my mind is that Ubisoft has a current track history of producing quality games."

Yup, and not only that; They have proven time and again that they can make good open world games.

So I think there is every reason to have hopes for this title.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
7 years ago

That's very true, Ubi doesn't put out crappy products.

New Report

Close