We haven't given you our Dead Island review yet but rest assured, it's coming. And we already told you that Resistance 3 is awesome.

We don't want to give anything away just yet concerning Techland's effort, but you can check out some very positive reviews elsewhere. Both games in question came out on Tuesday and with a loaded fall lineup, many consumers have adopted the following position: "With so many titles I want to buy in the coming months, I really only want to purchase one this week…but which one?" Yeah, we feel your pain. It isn't easy.

While R3 is a standard – albeit intense and satisfying – FPS, Dead Island features a more open format and role-playing-like elements. It also operates from a first-person perspective but clearly, these are two very different experiences. So what to do? Well, in truth, the one distributed by Deep Silver will offer more bang for your buck, as the single-player campaign can extend as far as 30 or 40 hours. However, if you happen to get into the multiplayer in Resistance 3 , that one gets the edge in terms of longevity. And what about technical achievement?

Well, if you care a lot about such things, neither title will impress the hell out of you. In fact, if you're a classic graphic whore, you're bound to harp on several drawbacks in both, despite R3's fantastic environment and atmosphere. Or, one could consider the "X factors;" i.e., I know some people who just don't care about zombies. They really won't play anything with zombies, and they don't care about an in-depth, survival-based zombie-slayin' adventure. And then there are others who just don't play shooters. If you fall into such categories, the decision is easy for you.

But for most gamers, it's not going to be an easy decision. We might end up recommending both (we definitely recommend Insomniac's newest), and we'd hardly be the only source to do so. We keep thinking both games should've arrived a month earlier; it would've given us a bigger buffer between "the decision" and the jam-packed fall lineup. Oh, and did we mention that a couple great HD Collections come out this month? You know, the God of War Origins Collection and the ICO & Shadow of the Colossus HD Collection ? …sorry.

Related Game(s): Resistance 3

Subscribe
Notify of
48 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
PasteNuggs
PasteNuggs
9 years ago

Well I have R3 so Dead Island will have to wait until the beginning of next year or until summer.

Danny007
Danny007
9 years ago

I've been enjoying both today, but if I had to choose… I would have to pick Resistance 3.

Gordo
Gordo
9 years ago

Wow. You have read my mind…

To get R3 for the polish and gameplay or Dead Island for the zombies and exploration?

I'm going to get one as I need something to play this month.

My heart says Dead Island but my head says Resistance 3.

Dancemachine55
Dancemachine55
9 years ago

Resistance 3 is preordered. Picking it up tomorrow.

I would really love to get my hands on Dead Island though, since I love Borderlands and Fallout 3, ie FPS and RPG mixed very well.

Dead Island I'm gonna wait for a price drop to somewhere around 30 or 35 bucks at OzGameShop. That is cheap where I come from, and a whole lot better than buying it at EB for $100.

Gordo
Gordo
9 years ago

Yip, no $100 game for me either. Probably get one from JB HIFI by trading in 3 games…

Need to see Ben's Dead Island review first to definately decide.

DIsmael85
DIsmael85
9 years ago

That's it I'm getting both. The decision is just to hard. 😛

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
9 years ago

I will get both, but not now. So I choose… WKC2.

Clamedeus
Clamedeus
9 years ago

Can't wait for WKC! 😀 I also want to get Dead Island as well.. I've been hearing very good things about it from friends who have it.

I might have to wait on it though. :/ Not a lot of money to use.

Dreno
Dreno
9 years ago

Likewise boss. Ill be waiting of DI for a price drop most likely. Butll I'm waiting til next Tuesday (13th) so I can d1p wkc2.

And I'm in the process right now, of gettin some net so I can. Join in on this psxe guild I read about in an earlier topic.

I actually suggested a psxe guild in on of my journels on wkc. This will be sweet.

johnld
johnld
9 years ago

i'm with you world, i'm not buying anything but wkc2 for now. i will borrow games from gamestop though, working on deus ex. kinda glad i never bought deus ex because i just cant get into the game.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
9 years ago

I'm getting bored with dues ex, prolly wont finish

Teddie9
Teddie9
9 years ago

yeah that's my circumstance as well.

Twistedfloyd
Twistedfloyd
9 years ago

R3 easily. Dead Island looks like garbage, zombies have been so over done. I have R3 and am going to be playing it later tonight. And I hate the fact that DI had that amazing trailer that doesn't represent at all what the game is.

It sounds interesting, but sort of just mindless let's go kill zombies.

R3 is a shooter with an emotional and brutal tale, and incredible multiplayer (the beat blew me away).

And I can't wait to fire that baby up.

Alienange
Alienange
9 years ago

Yeah. In fact, there's zombies in R3 too… bummer huh?

___________
___________
9 years ago

zombies have been overdone but post apocalyptic shooters have not?
if anything R3 is the overdone game of the two!

Sogi_Otsa
Sogi_Otsa
9 years ago

Resistance isn't really a good series. Dead island holds more then resistance. but imagine a sequel lol, it'd be unimaginable how much it'll move forward.

Clamedeus
Clamedeus
9 years ago

Most game settings have been done before. Nothing new, the only thing that matters is if the person enjoys it.

Alienange
Alienange
9 years ago

Dead Island looks dull. Kind of a poor man's Left 4 Dead. I don't see that competing with R3. Brain-dead zombie slaying is popular however (thanks Treyarch), so who knows…

ZettaiSeigi
ZettaiSeigi
9 years ago

Apparently they were going for realism hence the brain-dead zombies. LOL

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
9 years ago

Not fast and furious doesn't mean dull to me. Survival plus RPG doesn't really equal brain dead either.

Nlayer
Nlayer
9 years ago

I'm going with Dead Island. It looks like a game that I've been wanting to play for a very long time. I hope it delivers. I've never been much of a Resistance fan. Instead of buying number 3 I'll just finally start playing number 2 that I bought a long time ago.

Gabriel013
Gabriel013
9 years ago

I was really interested in Dead Island until the reviews I read suggested there are some really difficult areas with spawning 'runners' that are frustrating unless you are playing co-op. I wouldn't be.
I do not want to try to relax with a frustrating game.

I owned R1 and played it online a fair bit before I got bogged down even more in work hours. If I read that it has an exemplary single player then I might pick it up.

Turbey
Turbey
9 years ago

Well, I`ve already ordered Resistance 3…hoping I`ll get it today. And so far reviews for Resistance 3 have been really good (8`s and 9`s), so that`s good news. Same goes for Dead Island I guess, but I hear the story is pretty bad in that one. Will be buying it someday though; zombieslaying coop never get`s boring in my opinion.

But considering my internet is kinda kaputt, I think I`ll wait buying Dead Island for now.

Beamboom
Beamboom
9 years ago

R3 meta: 85%
DI meta: 75%

Not too tough a decision. 🙂 I'll get Dead Island after the first price drop though. But now is not the time to invest in a <80 rated game.


Last edited by Beamboom on 9/7/2011 1:32:56 AM

Excelsior1
Excelsior1
9 years ago

i agree wiith that. the metascore for r3 is 83 right now. di is 75. is it really that tough of a decision when one game scores much higher than the other? is ben implying he's going to score di near r3? i guess that would be consistent becuase review scores for dead island are all over the place.

johnld
johnld
9 years ago

i'll get resistance 3 when it drops in price a bit. i'll bite at 40 because white knight comes out in a week and theres no point in me buying resistance 3 then a week later lose myself in wkc2.

Lawless SXE
Lawless SXE
9 years ago

Resistance 3 tomorrow… Dead Island when it's going cheap. Not difficult. What is difficult is deciding whether also to pick up El Shaddai if I see it tomorrow or not…

Jed
Jed
9 years ago

I'm going R3 for now. I just can't ignore that franchise. They had the very best launch game for the PS3, and I really liked R2 as well, especially at the end. My loyalty is to Insomniac and R3. I'll check out DI later.

Beamboom
Beamboom
9 years ago

It's going to be extremely interesting to read how well coop play is done in Dead Island. Four player full campaign coop is pretty rare.


Last edited by Beamboom on 9/7/2011 4:03:58 AM

robinhood2010
robinhood2010
9 years ago

This is just another reason to own R3:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z-FRb8CZ__I&feature=youtube_gdata_player

Animated by Insomniac themselves.

Bloodysilence19
Bloodysilence19
9 years ago

I Picked DI, could never really get into Resistance its not a bad game at all, but I like smashing zombies faces in, it never gets to old imo.

gustave154
gustave154
9 years ago

bought both but played R3 first =)
got the survivor edition for R3 too.

AshT
AshT
9 years ago

although i'm tempted for dead island, resistance 3 is got my money

___________
___________
9 years ago

boring been there done that mindless shooter with nothing but brown, brown and more brown backdrop, and can be completed in roughly 7 hours.
or fun as hell funny zombie slasher with character customization, weapon customizations, RPG elements, heaps of replayability, 50+ hours, all draped in a beautiful tropical island backdrop.
easiest decision i have ever had to make!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
harder decision is if i should grab warhammer 40K or save my cash and put it towards one of next months games.

sirbob6
sirbob6
9 years ago

I just love the descriptions you used for each of them.

AugustoDeItalia
AugustoDeItalia
9 years ago

since i'm not a big fan of shooters, i picked up dead island yesterday, and i LOVE it !! But i'm sure the ones who picked up R3 are gonna enjoy it because i know it's a great game ! both games are must-buys if you want my opinion


Last edited by AugustoDeItalia on 9/7/2011 7:04:15 AM

TheOldOne
TheOldOne
9 years ago

I want a comparison of Dead Island with Dead Rising 2. Can anyone who has played both games do that, please. I loved DR2, btw.

TheOldOne
TheOldOne
9 years ago

No edit button again? It should have said:
"I want a comparison of Dead Island with Dead Rising 2. Can anyone who has played both games do that, please? I loved DR2, btw. "

PAKINIPS
PAKINIPS
9 years ago

Just to add a question mark?
O…k

Beamboom
Beamboom
9 years ago

I bet they are pretty hard to compare but I'd love to read that too.


Last edited by Beamboom on 9/8/2011 5:48:49 AM

erislocker
erislocker
9 years ago

i pre-ordered (and picked up) DI. i played till 3am yesterday. it was awesome! i'm super tried of FPS (and been never a big fan) but own many CODs and others. i really liked DI because of the open world exploration and the customization. plus doing melee weapons and knives and swords is f_cking awesome!
i'm happy with my purchase. can't wait for the Arena DLC unlock…

Evil Incarnate
Evil Incarnate
9 years ago

I couldn't make up my mind so, I bought both! I got Dead Island in the mail yesterday and should have Resistance 3 in the mailbox when I get home from work! Hellz yeah!

Krilldog
Krilldog
9 years ago

I just said F- it. I have 'em both. I don't like denying myself good gaming experiences. Great decision as both games are awesome.

Robochic
Robochic
9 years ago

For me I would love both right now I'm waiting for R3 when I have stuff paid off and I'll see what boxing day gives me for DI I love zombies but i've been up and down with this one.

JackDillinger89
JackDillinger89
9 years ago

Too bad the reviews for dead island are nowwhere close to glowing as R3 haha. I can rent dead island from blockbuster with there $1.99 daily fees beat it in 2-3 days and save $55 and buy R3 and rape the chimeran blood out of it online for months till bc3 and mw3 comes out.

hadouken
hadouken
9 years ago

What about Driver SF? I actually got that over resistance 3 and dead island. Damn you Nostalgia lol.

Teddie9
Teddie9
9 years ago

The beta was lacklustre if you ask me but the final copy is supposedly fantastic so I'm all for R3 since I'm thoroughly attached to the narrative.

JackDillinger89
JackDillinger89
9 years ago

I actually had a blast with the driver SF demo. Yeah it got average 70s but i will pick it up as a bargin bin price in the future im a fool for cockpit view and real world cars. But too many AAA titles out soon Just got R3, less than 2 weeks i get gears 3, then dark souls, then bf3, forza 4, mgs collection, mw3 and of course top of list Uncharted 3. I might of missed a few games. thats over $300-400 + on games and i got bills too.