So looking at the software data released today by the NPD caused me some confusion. There's no PS3 Beatles: Rock Band in the top 10, while the X360 and Wii versions are. On the otherhand, there's no Xbox 360 Batman in the top 10, while the PS3 version is. Guitar Hero 5 for the X360 barely cracked the charts, but the rest of the platforms didn't. Thankfully, a few additional details leaked out and we were able to find out the answers to our confusion.

First, take a gander the chart below. Halo: ODST placed number one as we all expected. The other thing worth mentioning is the sales of Madden NFL '10 for the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3, as the two versions continue performing well enough on both sides. Moving on, Marvel Ultimate Alliance 2 for X360 charted at number seven, but nowhere to be found for the PS3. Same goes for The Beatles. Oddly enough, PlayStation 3 sales of The Beatles: Rock Band were poor, a mere 132k sold. Compared to the Wii and X360 sales, that's very weak.

But, thanks to the exclusive content of the PlayStation 3, being able to play as the Joker, it seems that really helped the PS3 version of Batman outsell the Xbox 360 game by just over 10k units – not exactly a massive difference, but it goes to show that notable exclusive content helps drive sales. And lastly, tallying up sales for Guitar Hero 5 across all consoles brings the total to a pretty meager 500k units sold.

Ouch.

01. HALO 3: ODST (360; Sep-09) 1.52M
02. Wii SPORTS RESORT W/ WII MOTION PLUS (WII; Jul-09) 442.9K
03. MADDEN NFL 10 (360; Aug-09) 289.6K
04. MARIO & LUIGI:BOWSER'S INSIDE STORY (NDS; Sep-09) 258.1K
05. THE BEATLES:ROCK BAND* (360; Sep-09) 254.0K
06. MADDEN NFL 10 (PS3; Aug-09) 246.5K
07. MARVEL:ULTIMATE ALLIANCE 2 (360; Sep-09) 236.0K
08. BATMAN:ARKHAM ASYLUM* (PS3; Aug-09) 212.5K
09. GUITAR HERO 5* (360; Sep-09) 210.8K
10. THE BEATLES:ROCK BAND* (WII; Sep-09) 208.6K

xx. BATMAN:ARKHAM ASYLUM* (360; Aug-09) 202.0K+
xx. THE BEATLES:ROCK BAND* (PS3; Sep-09) 132.4K

Misc: GUITAR HERO 5 (All Platforms) – 499k

Subscribe
Notify of
28 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
yak4life85
yak4life85
11 years ago

Can't wait for next month, to see where Uncharted 2 will be stand.

Anyone else think Uncharted 2 will be number 1!

Snaaaake
Snaaaake
11 years ago

For me I think it will.
Owning a PS3 but not Uncharted 2 is a video game crime.
A great console without great game is just like sushi without wasabi.

Reccaman18
Reccaman18
11 years ago

Dude, I hate wasabi! I work with some Mexicans and they dont even touch it Which is saying something!

Qubex
Qubex
11 years ago

LLLOOOOOOOLLL! I take my hat off to Mexicans… not an easy handle!

Q!

"i am home"

Oxvial
Oxvial
11 years ago

I'm Mexican and I luv wasabi.

MasLB51
MasLB51
11 years ago

i LOVE sushi but i don't really like wasabi…..and im japenese….if that helps…

The_R0gue_Ninja
The_R0gue_Ninja
11 years ago

Um… I like Tabasco Sauce. 😛

shaydey77
shaydey77
11 years ago

I dont like ODST. I still think Halo 3 is fantastic fun but ODST just doesnt do it for me.
Uncharted should definitely be in the number one spot.

to_far_apart
to_far_apart
11 years ago

I thought the story of ODST was a good idea but it didn't appeal to me that much, i mean when you think of halo you think of Master chief. In my opinion, both halo 2 and 3 were okay, the stories weren't all that great and don't even get me started with the AI in halo 3…purely absurd. If anything what sparked such hype over the halo franchise was the amazing online play. Now don't get me wrong, let me clarify, the halo franchise is without a doubt an incredible franchise to begin with, but to me, the first halo still stand out above the others. I mean the immersive story at the time which surprised everyone, and not to mention the game which revolutionized online play. I believe Uncharted 2 should take the number 1 spot on the next poll, it's just to incredible.

telly
telly
11 years ago

I was having a great time plowing through the ODST campaign with a couple buddies of mine… and then it was over in like six hours. That should have cost 20 bucks, NOT 60. I really enjoy Halo, but it's not even the best space marines vs. aliens game on Xbox — Gears of War holds that distinction, easily.

I'll be interested to see where Halo goes from here. The ODST gameplay felt kind of silly and dated compared to Killzone 2 or Gears of War, quite honestly.

King James
King James
11 years ago

I think the PS3 Rock band thing is because most ppl who own PS3 know the gaming industry. They're not you're under 16 crowd or over 40 crowd.

The Beatles games was (IMO) marketed to the non-gamers heavy, which isn't aligned with the US target market for the PS3 (that doesn't mean that the PS3 Beatles didn't kill in EU…SingStar anyone?). I think ppl with PS3s got Rock Band Beatles on other consoles like the Wii. I know I would if I had one. The Wii's a party console. Rock Band's a party game. Crank your Wii out to entertain the house guests. Bust out the PS3 for real games. END.
——————————–

Now all that's left is for Uncharted 2 to sit on top of October's charts…Then the US transformation will begin. Sony is back on top in the US and M$ is back to a niche product.

Does anybody else get the feeling that Uncharted 2 will outsell Halo: Recon for the holiday season?

Xbox games don't sell all that great in the long-run (The Hare). PS3 games do (The Tortoise).

to_far_apart
to_far_apart
11 years ago

don't quote me on this either, just personal opinion, but they're just milking the cow out of the halo franchise until they release a full fledged sequel (number 4) for the next xbox to drive sales =P

bomba2812
bomba2812
11 years ago

yeah they made halo wars and odst just to make a quick buck

Banky A
Banky A
11 years ago

You betcha' I'm going to quote you!

/nerd rage

SHADOW
SHADOW
11 years ago

I won't disagree that they're milking Halo with ODST but Halo Wars was a damn good game in its own right. It's just too bad Essemble couldn't have gone out on a franchise of their own.

to_far_apart
to_far_apart
11 years ago

well they made a pretty penny with those games 😉 lol alright, if i end up being right, definitely quote me =P lol

telly
telly
11 years ago

no doubt about it. Nothing wrong with spinoffs, necessarily, but yeah, ODST cost as much as Halo 3 and didn't offer NEARLY as much. Total cash grab.

Jawknee
Jawknee
11 years ago

Gaw I really don't understand the love for Halo. The other day I went to my local target, some geek working there was talking to his co-worker hating on Uncharted 2. Making fun of the puzzles and platforming. He said "Master Cheif don't let puzzles get in his way". I almost spit ice tea everywhere.

I don't know what his problem was. Any rational person can see Uncharted 2 is miles better.

WolfCrimson
WolfCrimson
11 years ago

Isn't it obvious? He's an Xbot! Xbot's are never rational.

SnipeySnake
SnipeySnake
11 years ago

"Master Cheif don't let puzzles get in his way", lol, i just can't help but laugh at that.

Oxvial
Oxvial
11 years ago

funny thing no matter what Masterchief do triying to look badass.. he still is one of the mos uncharismatic characters I ever see.

Buckeyestar
Buckeyestar
11 years ago

Well, the sad truth is that a high percentage of American male gamers can't get into any game that isn't sports, racing or another FPS fragfest. Out of all the people I work with who have PS3s (about 5 or 6), I'm the only one who has Uncharted 2, all they can think about is MW2 or any game similar. No matter how much I try to convince them, they never even downloaded the demo. One guy did just buy it, but he got it for his 6 year old kid. A large portion of male gamers in this country sadly only care about fragfests, that's why I voted that MW2 would be game of the year even though I think Uncharted 2 deserves it hands down.


Last edited by Buckeyestar on 10/20/2009 8:33:49 AM

SnipeySnake
SnipeySnake
11 years ago

The only game i would buy in that list would be mario and luigi bowers inside story. (even though i dont have a ds lol).

As for ODST being first. People in this world are stupid, period.


Last edited by SnipeySnake on 10/19/2009 10:59:27 PM

cadpig
cadpig
11 years ago

Get real, show me a game company that won't milk a money making franchise. Halo 3: ODST is a pretty good game. I won't knock it.
Uncharted 2 might take Oct, Tekken 6 could throw an upset. Nov is Call of duty modern warfare 2

chucknasty
chucknasty
11 years ago

Sadly I will agree. Yet another tired rehash of the army FPS genre will sell two million games on day one. I really wish that FPSs would either evolve to something that would be enjoyable to play or people would quit buying the same game with a slightly different skin again and again and again.

___________
___________
11 years ago

HA!
take that moneyvision.
thats what happens when you run your mouth off and screw us gamers around.
not even all the adds in the world can save you now, but seriously thats really starting to piss me off.
every single add break, i mean EVERY SINGLE FU**ING ONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
has a add for GH5.
there should be a limitation to how many adds a certain product can have.
O and where are the uncharted 2 adds?
sony?
yea, i thought so.
when O when will sony learn you have to spend money to make money.
talk about deaf as a door nob!


Last edited by ___________ on 10/20/2009 12:22:27 AM

Troy Powers
Troy Powers
11 years ago

Didn't an Activision rep say GH5 was outselling The Beatles: Rock Band? According to this list it's GH 500k, B:RB 600k. Or, was it the month before they were bragging about that?

Robochic
Robochic
11 years ago

Can't wait for next month either to see where uncharted 2 and demons souls is at cause I know that every retailer where I live is sold out of demons souls (not suprised) glad I preordered.

For Halo to win not suprised but not sure why either, its the same everything just new maps.