Halloween is upon us once again and in honor of the creepy holiday, we want to know:

What's the one game you've played that actually gave you nightmares? The one that was legitimately freaky and made you jump out of your seat? The one you loved and hated to play with the lights off at 2 a.m.? In other words, what is the scariest damn game you've ever played?

One of the more recent titles that got to me was Outlast . I think it was how the horror adventure was structured; it was well paced and whenever you're no superhero, things are that much scarier. In fact, the less equipped you are, the more afraid you are (in most cases). Another game that I found quite unsettling was Alan Wake , which wasn't exactly a horror game – it was more of a dark psychological thriller – but its atmosphere was wicked good. No matter what you were doing or where you were, you always had this sense that something awfully unpleasant lurked around the corner. That's what any good scary game or movie does, right?

Perhaps the scariest of all time would have to go to Silent Hill 2 for me. It was a combination of great audio (using subtle noises to continually freak you out) and limited visibility (something is out there but where ?) that preyed on your emotions. Never actually seeing something but allowing your imagination to run wild sits at the core of every truly terrifying experience. Oh yeah, and that demo for Silent Hills had an effect on me as well; it sucks that the project got axed. Guillermo Del Toro didn't like it, either .

So, what's on your list?

Subscribe
Notify of
36 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Temjin001
Temjin001
5 years ago

Final Fantasy XIII

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
5 years ago

haha, were you running in a straight line that never ended?

pavlovic
pavlovic
5 years ago

Clock Tower. It actually gave my nightmares, I dreamed more than once with that scissors guy

Kevin555
Kevin555
5 years ago

That was an incredible game for it's time.

Oxvial
Oxvial
4 years ago

This!, fortunately I wasn't a kid when I tried that one (used a emulator after read an article about horror games from a magazine), as a kid I just can't imagine how I would deal with this game if I had it for my Super nes.


Last edited by Oxvial on 11/1/2015 2:20:38 PM

Zemus101
Zemus101
5 years ago

The ending sequence of Parasite Eve scared the hell outta me. Too much Resident Evil in my RPG! 😉

Jawknee
Jawknee
5 years ago

Resident Evil Remake when it was released for GameCube was pretty freaky deaky. The tension building in the game kept me from wanting to continue.

Jalex
Jalex
5 years ago

Probably the one that stayed with me the longest after playing it was 'Rule of Rose' on PlayStation 2. The gameplay is average, but the story and atmosphere are great, and something about it just wouldn't quit pestering me for a while after I finished.

Ben Dutka PSXE
Ben Dutka PSXE
5 years ago

I remember that game…pretty freaky.

Kevin555
Kevin555
5 years ago

Silent Hill 3 did it for me with it's nightmarish imagery which was clearly evident in the games atmosphere. Some of the twisted goings-on happening in the background made it very disturbing.

Forbidden Siren 2 would be another one, the bizarre blend of human with bug/insect appendages gave me the creeps. There are some creatures in that game that i still can't unsee to this day.

Finally, P.T….unfathomable amounts of nope!!


Last edited by Kevin555 on 10/31/2015 12:14:41 PM

PC_Max
PC_Max
5 years ago

No.1 for me was Silent Hill with the radio static and then something coming out of the darkness at me. Heck just about everything in it. Silent Hill 2 had its moments as well including Pyramid Head.

Fatal Frame gave me a few shivers up the spine as well I can tell you.

Keep playing!

Corvo
Corvo
5 years ago

Siren on the ps3 screwed me up too. That chanting… Hearing it right as you fell asleep, did some nasty things to your dreams.

I think Silent Hill 4s Twins though gave me the most nightmares. That and the overwhelming sense that not even the hub world is safe as the spirits start to make sounds, and appear. It spooked me real nice back in the day. I miss it.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
5 years ago

DOOM. My friend and I used to play it non stop after school and weekends. So we both started having these "Doom nightmares" we called them. The game wasn't scary of course, but the nightmares are.

Breadlover
Breadlover
5 years ago

I hate to say it but… Dino Crisis… yeah, I was a scaredy cat 🙁

… I couldn't even play P.T. on my own. I would try it, then after entering the hallway, I would close the app and play a little bit of Dead or Alive just to forget about the dark place… I live alone, btw.

BikerSaint
BikerSaint
4 years ago

I'm thinking the 1st two Manhunt & F.E.A.R. games, were quite freaky-deaky.

And not sure if I remember right since it was so far back & I no longer have it, but I thinking that I'd give the original Splatterhouse an honorable mention too.

Solaire
Solaire
4 years ago

Amnesia: The Dark Descent.

Underdog15
Underdog15
4 years ago

Mortal Combat. Used to dream about Goro tearing me apart. lol

gumbi
gumbi
4 years ago

The only game that has ever given me actual nightmares, the kind where you wake up in a panic, is Max Payne. It was those awful hallucination dream sequences about his wife and baby. Gut wrenching.

Zemus101
Zemus101
1 year ago

The ending sequence of Parasite Eve scared the hell outta me. Too much Resident Evil in my RPG! 😉

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
1 year ago

haha, were you running in a straight line that never ended?

pavlovic
pavlovic
1 year ago

Clock Tower. It actually gave my nightmares, I dreamed more than once with that scissors guy

Breadlover
Breadlover
1 year ago

I hate to say it but… Dino Crisis… yeah, I was a scaredy cat 🙁

… I couldn&#39t even play P.T. on my own. I would try it, then after entering the hallway, I would close the app and play a little bit of Dead or Alive just to forget about the dark place… I live alone, btw.

Jawknee
Jawknee
1 year ago

Resident Evil Remake when it was released for GameCube was pretty freaky deaky. The tension building in the game kept me from wanting to continue.

Ben Dutka PSXE
Ben Dutka PSXE
1 year ago

I remember that game…pretty freaky.

Temjin001
Temjin001
1 year ago

Final Fantasy XIII

Corvo
Corvo
1 year ago

Siren on the ps3 screwed me up too. That chanting… Hearing it right as you fell asleep, did some nasty things to your dreams.

I think Silent Hill 4s Twins though gave me the most nightmares. That and the overwhelming sense that not even the hub world is safe as the spirits start to make sounds, and appear. It spooked me real nice back in the day. I miss it.

PC_Max
PC_Max
1 year ago

No.1 for me was Silent Hill with the radio static and then something coming out of the darkness at me. Heck just about everything in it. Silent Hill 2 had its moments as well including Pyramid Head.

Fatal Frame gave me a few shivers up the spine as well I can tell you.

Keep playing!

Jalex
Jalex
1 year ago

Probably the one that stayed with me the longest after playing it was &#39Rule of Rose&#39 on PlayStation 2. The gameplay is average, but the story and atmosphere are great, and something about it just wouldn&#39t quit pestering me for a while after I finished.

Kevin555
Kevin555
1 year ago

Silent Hill 3 did it for me with it&#39s nightmarish imagery which was clearly evident in the games atmosphere. Some of the twisted goings-on happening in the background made it very disturbing.

Forbidden Siren 2 would be another one, the bizarre blend of human with bug/insect appendages gave me the creeps. There are some creatures in that game that i still can&#39t unsee to this day.

Finally, P.T….unfathomable amounts of nope!!

Last edited by Kevin555 on 10/31/2015 12:14:41 PM

Solaire
Solaire
1 year ago

Amnesia: The Dark Descent.

BikerSaint
BikerSaint
1 year ago

I&#39m thinking the 1st two Manhunt & F.E.A.R. games, were quite freaky-deaky.

And not sure if I remember right since it was so far back & I no longer have it, but I thinking that I&#39d give the original Splatterhouse an honorable mention too.

gumbi
gumbi
1 year ago

The only game that has ever given me actual nightmares, the kind where you wake up in a panic, is Max Payne. It was those awful hallucination dream sequences about his wife and baby. Gut wrenching.

WorldEndsWithMe
WorldEndsWithMe
1 year ago

DOOM. My friend and I used to play it non stop after school and weekends. So we both started having these "Doom nightmares" we called them. The game wasn&#39t scary of course, but the nightmares are.

Underdog15
Underdog15
1 year ago

Mortal Combat. Used to dream about Goro tearing me apart. lol

Kevin555
Kevin555
1 year ago

That was an incredible game for it&#39s time.

Oxvial
Oxvial
1 year ago

This!, fortunately I wasn&#39t a kid when I tried that one (used a emulator after read an article about horror games from a magazine), as a kid I just can&#39t imagine how I would deal with this game if I had it for my Super nes.

Last edited by Oxvial on 11/1/2015 2:20:38 PM