Time changes perspectives.

There was a time when Nintendo vs. Sega was the ultimate console war and nobody could conceive of a more gripping or legendary battle. In retrospect, it didn't even last that long, not compared to PlayStation vs. Xbox.

There's no doubt that Nintendo will go down in history as a pioneer in the industry. But as the years and decades fall away, one's going to have to ask the serious question: Can PlayStation/Sony go toe-to-toe with Nintendo in terms of overall brand impact on gaming? Is it feasible that in fact, PlayStation will end up being just as important to this industry in the long run, if not more so? One could make the argument that with the same mascots for three decades, Nintendo hasn't done enough to maintain its forward momentum. And without the motion-sensing gimmick that rocketed the Wii to temporary superstar-dom, Nintendo might not even be in the console race anymore.

At the same time, you can't say the N64 wasn't instrumental in the inception and evolution of 3D gaming. PlayStation participated there, too, but I imagine everyone will remember Mario 64 as the game that helped break the mold, that allowed everyone to see what a new generation – and a new dimension – would be like. Even so, if you look at the birth and expansion of various genres, I think it's obvious that the original PlayStation (and in fact, all PlayStations) had a wider variety of gameplay experiences, from the likes of Metal Gear Solid to JRPGs to the first simulators. This diversity is really what allowed the PlayStation brand to dominate the industry; the PS2 had just about every conceivable genre on earth, while the same could not be said of GameCube and Xbox, for instance.

Again, time is the key. For the time being, I doubt anyone will say Sony is "as iconic" as Nintendo. Well, perhaps nostalgia is playing a role…a big role. And maybe we should start to acknowledge that.

Subscribe
Notify of
42 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Phoenix
Phoenix
5 years ago

Eh…. I don't think it's nostalgia at all, Nintendo had how many EPIC franchises? PS has who exactly? yea, not much, and they're no where near what Nintendo has.

Now, today's youth I'd wager would 100% agree with you that the PS is as Iconic( if not more so ), they didn't grow up in an age of Nintendo, so they've never played the classics, MB1/2/3, Super Mario World, Donkey Kong Country, LoZ, LoZ: ALTTP, Kirby games, Metroid games, Castlevania NES/SNES games, SM64, the list is endless. So, those of us that have been around , or have looked into the oldies know that when you think of games, you think Nintendo.

GMRX
GMRX
5 years ago

I think you're missing the point though, we are talking the entire brand here, not just the games.

Nintendo single handedly brought back the gaming industry from the clutches of death back then and was made famous for such titles as Mario, Zelda etc.

But what have they actually done since then? Other than their same old repeat franchises (which are admittedly successful, but still repeats), their consoles have been mediocre to flops (bar their handheld consoles which have a lifespan, phones are the new way to mobile game and they're more powerful than a 3DS could ever be) and if it wasn't for their games and gimmicks, they'd be like Sega by now, making games for the other two consoles.

Cube was rubbish, I'm sorry, but it was. It had limited potential from the start. Wii only did well because of the gimmick and as soon as people discovered how boring it got, it was dropped faster than a hot kettle and as for Wii U, don't even get me started.

That's three generations of sub par to below par consoles, with Wii and Gameboy being the only things sustaining them. For a child born of today, I wouldn't think anything of Nintendo and children of today have more tech buying power than we ever did.

So for nostalgia's sake, Nintendo for us oldies is the one true icon, but lets be honest, they were dethroned by Xbox and Playstation some time ago. Tell a kid today about Nintendo and they'll laugh at you :/


Last edited by GMRX on 8/22/2015 7:31:19 PM

Bio
Bio
5 years ago

Been more an icon of the industey than Nintendo for a while now.

Underdog15
Underdog15
5 years ago

For a younger demographic aged early 20's and under?

Absolutely.

For those of us who remember NES when it was the new system of the day? Probably not.

Rachet_JC_FTW
Rachet_JC_FTW
5 years ago

yeah thats a fair statement

cLoudou
cLoudou
5 years ago

Yep, the original PlayStation,and the PlayStation 2 dominated the market, and now the PS4 is poised to do the same if not on pace to overtake the PS2.

They may not have the iconic first party games and characters as Nintendo, but the PlayStation is home to maybe more great exclusive titles than Nintendo.

Phoenix
Phoenix
5 years ago

Sales numbers aside, you really think that the PS brand is really as iconic as Nintendo? honestly?

You bring up exclusives, and while I'll grant you during the ps1/ps2 days this was very true( all the FF titles, GT, the boat load of JRPGs, etc ), it's not anymore, most of the ps3/ps4 big titles are multi platform now, while throughout the many years since the NES ( or game and watch ), Nintendo has had the best exclusives imo, but also has kept the big titles where as PS has not.

So, in the end Nintendo has kept all their exclusives ( unless you count that brief moment with the CD-I), has far bigger brand recognition , and imo, better/funner games.

GMRX
GMRX
5 years ago

PS is more iconic, maybe not in history overall, but at the moment it is a more iconic brand worldwide. More kids and adults alike today know about, have and / or WANT a Playstation than they do a Nintendo and that alone = Iconic :/

Nintendo holds the "iconic" title because of four major things.

– How it revived the games industry
– Gameboy
– Innovation
– Franchises

Kids today don't care about the revival of the games industry, gameboy is doing well now, but phones have pretty much ensured that there may never be another gameboy to top the 3DS models. Their idea of innovation has been a bit lacking as of late and their franchises are great, but repeats.

Your point about games going multiplat is moot too, because by multiplat we are only talking PC and Xbox here, both of which are also more iconic than Nintendo is now. Whether or not Nintendo keeps its exclusives to itself doesn't change how the once big titan of the games industry has fallen from grace. In fact, its only the games that Nintendo has going for it any more.

The fact that nobody talks about Nintendo and when they do, they think of a Nintendo console as a console you buy WITH another console and never on its own is testament. Nobody ever says Nintendo vs Playstation vs Xbox, they only ever say Xbox vs Playstation. We forget that Nintendo even exists in conversation.

Draguss
Draguss
5 years ago

I do not have enough information to make an educated guess, but at least my parents stopped calling it a nintendo when I got the ps3.

Snaaaake
Snaaaake
5 years ago

Yes it is.
Reason is that the PS brand is officially the biggest console brand in the world, even bigger than Ninty's consoles.
However, Ninty has been dominating the handheld since the beginning, the DS sold more than 100 million units while the 3DS is already at 50 million.
And let's not forget about Pokemon, I once read that the Pokemon franchise generates $1.5 Billion annually.

So yea, they're pretty much on even ground now.

Rachet_JC_FTW
Rachet_JC_FTW
5 years ago

yeah pokemon is a good point i got a 3DS for pokemon in 2013 so thats a point like i said

Rachet_JC_FTW
Rachet_JC_FTW
5 years ago

now yeah sure PlayStation is pritty iconic from the 90's til today and yeah for those of you who came from the 80's the NES and SNES for you guys is what the ps1 and ps2 has been like for us 90's kids so i see what ur saying in respects.

so to slightly different demographics and generations and i know that nintendo was huge 30 years ago and is still big, but now but playstation is well bigger.

i guess if you think about it a bit playstation today is what nintendo was in the 80's and until the ps1 arrived on the scene in the early 90's along side the N64 which was a great system in its own right.

but yeah its a good question to ask.

happy gaming


Last edited by Rachet_JC_FTW on 8/22/2015 8:33:33 AM

Temjin001
Temjin001
5 years ago

Nintendo had the rare opportunity to revitalize a dieing market with the NES.
Sony successfully took consoles to being an acceptable multimedia entertainment solution with PS2.
Sony created first party software that had lots of diversity, much like Hollywood entertainment. Gran Turismo, God of War, MLB the Show, LBP, Killzone, Ratchet, Heavy Rain etc.
Nintendo stubbornly clung to being like a toy in the market in both software and hardware. They avoided being seen as anything other than a games machine with software that had icons that kids would be sure to love. Today Nintendo feels like a children's toy maker. Sony feels like multimedia entertainment that cultivates diversity.


Last edited by Temjin001 on 8/22/2015 10:19:21 AM

Aranha
Aranha
5 years ago

For as much as I want to say Nintendo (and you and I have gone back and forth about this in previous articles Ben), I do have to say Sony has become just as iconic and even more important now to gaming, than Nintendo.

When people start calling every game system now a "PlayStation", the way people used to refer to games systems of the 80s and early 90s as a "Nintendo", then yeah, it's become iconic.

I love Nintendo, and they definitely made their mark in the industry as pioneers, pulling the gaming industry out of a catastrophic death. But let's face it, Nintendo's best systems, and I mean most memorable, would have to be the original NES and the SNES. None of their newer systems, despite what they introduced, made people marvel at their accomplishments like those 2 systems.

Sony on the other hand practically re-invents gaming with every system. And I don't mean that they're being extremely innovative, but it knows how to dominate every generation because Sony has staying power. It has a strong presence every generation where you know Sony is out there, and has a system capable of playing so many types of games and genres, caters to so many demographics.

I guess you can say Nintendo hasn't kept up, and I don't mean with more mature games, but just in the fact that Nintendo has made it obvious that they're not looking to expand beyond where they're at; their relations with developers and 3rd-party support has always been week and gotten worse, and they hardly branch away from their usual mascots and 1st-party lineup. And they don't have to stop making their 1st-party production, but they don't seem to think that there's room for both 1st and 3rd-party support with their systems.

Nintendo is not staying as relevant to gaming as Sony and even Microsoft at this point. I'm actually afraid for them, which is sad to say of a company that I considered to be legendary at one point.

I guess what it boils down to is the experience each company and their system provides. While I have fun on Nintendo systems and their traditional mascot games, I am always wowed by Sony and the experiences it provides. Despite the NES and SNES opening the doors for gaming to me as a child, I can't think of any other systems that blew my mind as much as Sony's PS1, PS2, and even still, PS3.

The CEO
The CEO
5 years ago

Probably more iconic. They don't have to rely on a goofy plumber that has a shroom problem.

GMRX
GMRX
5 years ago

Playstation has become iconic, so much so that you would definitely feel it if it ever vanished one day.

Okay, they haven't been the best with innovation, their games aren't as renowned as Nintendo's, they often copy everyone else in the industry, they've had some funny and frankly embarrassing moments, but you know, Sony and Playstation are like a loyal dog, it's dopey as hell half the time, but you love it all the same.

Sony has had a history you have to smile at, they've had ups and downs and anyone who is a fan of their consoles knows that it's like supporting your favourite sports team, you know they will have moments when they drop and you have to facepalm, but you are so much more proud of them when they reach the top again. Those superstar moments that make gamers everywhere scream with glee and they know better than ANYONE in the games industry how to do it.

They withstood the Sega vs Playstation era, they've withstood the Nintendo vs Playstation era, they've withstood the Xbox vs Playstation era, they've even withstood the Onlive vs Playstation era, the PSP / Vita vs all gaming only handheld systems ever invented battle and ONLY lost against Nintendo.

They managed to sell the PS3 at a frankly stupid price with a silly minuscule amount of games, if that's not a feat, I don't know what is. They've been mocked, shamelessly copied everything from everyone giving PS fans a little bit (albeit mediocre iteration at times) of everything that everyone else has and to be honest had the funniest E3 presentations in history. I always look forward to a Sony presser because I always know there is going to be a moment in it that will be made into a famous meme.

Playstation is iconic because it's been through everything and those who have stuck by it from the beginning know that better than anyone.

Jawknee
Jawknee
5 years ago

No. At least not yet. To the general population when you ask them to think of the first game mascot that comes to mind they will usually say Mario.

GMRX
GMRX
5 years ago

Game mascot, not "gaming brand".

That demonstrates that people put a game from Nintendo at a higher pedestal than Nintendo themselves.

Again, it's like your favourite sports team, you like a player from the team because he / she is the best in the world, you just don't care much for the team itself. Which means the player is iconic, the team, not so much.

Underdog15
Underdog15
5 years ago

The better question to answer what this article is talking about is to ask them to name a video game system.

I bet in NA you're more likely to get XBOX or Playstation than "Nintendo".

Hexen
Hexen
5 years ago

Well Nintendo was the most Iconic ever with great systems but after their last two toddler friendly systems and turning their franchises into cheap whores I view them as less iconic and relevant than Xbox.

squibbfire
squibbfire
5 years ago

Yes..their Controller is iconic..being the first mega successful CD run console is iconic. Metal Gear Solid is iconic god of war resident evil…final fantasy…its hard to compare since nintendo was first

Rachet_JC_FTW
Rachet_JC_FTW
1 year ago

yeah thats a fair statement

Rachet_JC_FTW
Rachet_JC_FTW
1 year ago

yeah pokemon is a good point i got a 3DS for pokemon in 2013 so thats a point like i said

Phoenix
Phoenix
1 year ago

Sales numbers aside, you really think that the PS brand is really as iconic as Nintendo? honestly?

You bring up exclusives, and while I&#39ll grant you during the ps1/ps2 days this was very true( all the FF titles, GT, the boat load of JRPGs, etc ), it&#39s not anymore, most of the ps3/ps4 big titles are multi platform now, while throughout the many years since the NES ( or game and watch ), Nintendo has had the best exclusives imo, but also has kept the big titles where as PS has not.

So, in the end Nintendo has kept all their exclusives ( unless you count that brief moment with the CD-I), has far bigger brand recognition , and imo, better/funner games.

GMRX
GMRX
1 year ago

PS is more iconic, maybe not in history overall, but at the moment it is a more iconic brand worldwide. More kids and adults alike today know about, have and / or WANT a Playstation than they do a Nintendo and that alone = Iconic :/

Nintendo holds the "iconic" title because of four major things.

– How it revived the games industry
– Gameboy
– Innovation
– Franchises

Kids today don&#39t care about the revival of the games industry, gameboy is doing well now, but phones have pretty much ensured that there may never be another gameboy to top the 3DS models. Their idea of innovation has been a bit lacking as of late and their franchises are great, but repeats.

Your point about games going multiplat is moot too, because by multiplat we are only talking PC and Xbox here, both of which are also more iconic than Nintendo is now. Whether or not Nintendo keeps its exclusives to itself doesn&#39t change how the once big titan of the games industry has fallen from grace. In fact, its only the games that Nintendo has going for it any more.

The fact that nobody talks about Nintendo and when they do, they think of a Nintendo console as a console you buy WITH another console and never on its own is testament. Nobody ever says Nintendo vs Playstation vs Xbox, they only ever say Xbox vs Playstation. We forget that Nintendo even exists in conversation.

Bio
Bio
1 year ago

Been more an icon of the industey than Nintendo for a while now.

Underdog15
Underdog15
1 year ago

For a younger demographic aged early 20&#39s and under?

Absolutely.

For those of us who remember NES when it was the new system of the day? Probably not.

cLoudou
cLoudou
1 year ago

Yep, the original PlayStation,and the PlayStation 2 dominated the market, and now the PS4 is poised to do the same if not on pace to overtake the PS2.

They may not have the iconic first party games and characters as Nintendo, but the PlayStation is home to maybe more great exclusive titles than Nintendo.

Phoenix
Phoenix
1 year ago

Eh…. I don&#39t think it&#39s nostalgia at all, Nintendo had how many EPIC franchises? PS has who exactly? yea, not much, and they&#39re no where near what Nintendo has.

Now, today&#39s youth I&#39d wager would 100% agree with you that the PS is as Iconic( if not more so ), they didn&#39t grow up in an age of Nintendo, so they&#39ve never played the classics, MB1/2/3, Super Mario World, Donkey Kong Country, LoZ, LoZ: ALTTP, Kirby games, Metroid games, Castlevania NES/SNES games, SM64, the list is endless. So, those of us that have been around , or have looked into the oldies know that when you think of games, you think Nintendo.

GMRX
GMRX
1 year ago

I think you&#39re missing the point though, we are talking the entire brand here, not just the games.

Nintendo single handedly brought back the gaming industry from the clutches of death back then and was made famous for such titles as Mario, Zelda etc.

But what have they actually done since then? Other than their same old repeat franchises (which are admittedly successful, but still repeats), their consoles have been mediocre to flops (bar their handheld consoles which have a lifespan, phones are the new way to mobile game and they&#39re more powerful than a 3DS could ever be) and if it wasn&#39t for their games and gimmicks, they&#39d be like Sega by now, making games for the other two consoles.

Cube was rubbish, I&#39m sorry, but it was. It had limited potential from the start. Wii only did well because of the gimmick and as soon as people discovered how boring it got, it was dropped faster than a hot kettle and as for Wii U, don&#39t even get me started.

That&#39s three generations of sub par to below par consoles, with Wii and Gameboy being the only things sustaining them. For a child born of today, I wouldn&#39t think anything of Nintendo and children of today have more tech buying power than we ever did.

So for nostalgia&#39s sake, Nintendo for us oldies is the one true icon, but lets be honest, they were dethroned by Xbox and Playstation some time ago. Tell a kid today about Nintendo and they&#39ll laugh at you :/

Last edited by GMRX on 8/22/2015 7:31:19 PM

Rachet_JC_FTW
Rachet_JC_FTW
1 year ago

now yeah sure PlayStation is pritty iconic from the 90&#39s til today and yeah for those of you who came from the 80&#39s the NES and SNES for you guys is what the ps1 and ps2 has been like for us 90&#39s kids so i see what ur saying in respects.

so to slightly different demographics and generations and i know that nintendo was huge 30 years ago and is still big, but now but playstation is well bigger.

i guess if you think about it a bit playstation today is what nintendo was in the 80&#39s and until the ps1 arrived on the scene in the early 90&#39s along side the N64 which was a great system in its own right.

but yeah its a good question to ask.

happy gaming

Last edited by Rachet_JC_FTW on 8/22/2015 8:33:33 AM

Snaaaake
Snaaaake
1 year ago

Yes it is.
Reason is that the PS brand is officially the biggest console brand in the world, even bigger than Ninty&#39s consoles.
However, Ninty has been dominating the handheld since the beginning, the DS sold more than 100 million units while the 3DS is already at 50 million.
And let&#39s not forget about Pokemon, I once read that the Pokemon franchise generates $1.5 Billion annually.

So yea, they&#39re pretty much on even ground now.

Temjin001
Temjin001
1 year ago

Nintendo had the rare opportunity to revitalize a dieing market with the NES.
Sony successfully took consoles to being an acceptable multimedia entertainment solution with PS2.
Sony created first party software that had lots of diversity, much like Hollywood entertainment. Gran Turismo, God of War, MLB the Show, LBP, Killzone, Ratchet, Heavy Rain etc.
Nintendo stubbornly clung to being like a toy in the market in both software and hardware. They avoided being seen as anything other than a games machine with software that had icons that kids would be sure to love. Today Nintendo feels like a children&#39s toy maker. Sony feels like multimedia entertainment that cultivates diversity.

Last edited by Temjin001 on 8/22/2015 10:19:21 AM

GMRX
GMRX
1 year ago

Game mascot, not "gaming brand".

That demonstrates that people put a game from Nintendo at a higher pedestal than Nintendo themselves.

Again, it&#39s like your favourite sports team, you like a player from the team because he / she is the best in the world, you just don&#39t care much for the team itself. Which means the player is iconic, the team, not so much.

Draguss
Draguss
1 year ago

I do not have enough information to make an educated guess, but at least my parents stopped calling it a nintendo when I got the ps3.

Aranha
Aranha
1 year ago

For as much as I want to say Nintendo (and you and I have gone back and forth about this in previous articles Ben), I do have to say Sony has become just as iconic and even more important now to gaming, than Nintendo.

When people start calling every game system now a "PlayStation", the way people used to refer to games systems of the 80s and early 90s as a "Nintendo", then yeah, it&#39s become iconic.

I love Nintendo, and they definitely made their mark in the industry as pioneers, pulling the gaming industry out of a catastrophic death. But let&#39s face it, Nintendo&#39s best systems, and I mean most memorable, would have to be the original NES and the SNES. None of their newer systems, despite what they introduced, made people marvel at their accomplishments like those 2 systems.

Sony on the other hand practically re-invents gaming with every system. And I don&#39t mean that they&#39re being extremely innovative, but it knows how to dominate every generation because Sony has staying power. It has a strong presence every generation where you know Sony is out there, and has a system capable of playing so many types of games and genres, caters to so many demographics.

I guess you can say Nintendo hasn&#39t kept up, and I don&#39t mean with more mature games, but just in the fact that Nintendo has made it obvious that they&#39re not looking to expand beyond where they&#39re at; their relations with developers and 3rd-party support has always been week and gotten worse, and they hardly branch away from their usual mascots and 1st-party lineup. And they don&#39t have to stop making their 1st-party production, but they don&#39t seem to think that there&#39s room for both 1st and 3rd-party support with their systems.

Nintendo is not staying as relevant to gaming as Sony and even Microsoft at this point. I&#39m actually afraid for them, which is sad to say of a company that I considered to be legendary at one point.

I guess what it boils down to is the experience each company and their system provides. While I have fun on Nintendo systems and their traditional mascot games, I am always wowed by Sony and the experiences it provides. Despite the NES and SNES opening the doors for gaming to me as a child, I can&#39t think of any other systems that blew my mind as much as Sony&#39s PS1, PS2, and even still, PS3.

Jawknee
Jawknee
1 year ago

No. At least not yet. To the general population when you ask them to think of the first game mascot that comes to mind they will usually say Mario.

The CEO
The CEO
1 year ago

Probably more iconic. They don&#39t have to rely on a goofy plumber that has a shroom problem.

GMRX
GMRX
1 year ago

Playstation has become iconic, so much so that you would definitely feel it if it ever vanished one day.

Okay, they haven&#39t been the best with innovation, their games aren&#39t as renowned as Nintendo&#39s, they often copy everyone else in the industry, they&#39ve had some funny and frankly embarrassing moments, but you know, Sony and Playstation are like a loyal dog, it&#39s dopey as hell half the time, but you love it all the same.

Sony has had a history you have to smile at, they&#39ve had ups and downs and anyone who is a fan of their consoles knows that it&#39s like supporting your favourite sports team, you know they will have moments when they drop and you have to facepalm, but you are so much more proud of them when they reach the top again. Those superstar moments that make gamers everywhere scream with glee and they know better than ANYONE in the games industry how to do it.

They withstood the Sega vs Playstation era, they&#39ve withstood the Nintendo vs Playstation era, they&#39ve withstood the Xbox vs Playstation era, they&#39ve even withstood the Onlive vs Playstation era, the PSP / Vita vs all gaming only handheld systems ever invented battle and ONLY lost against Nintendo.

They managed to sell the PS3 at a frankly stupid price with a silly minuscule amount of games, if that&#39s not a feat, I don&#39t know what is. They&#39ve been mocked, shamelessly copied everything from everyone giving PS fans a little bit (albeit mediocre iteration at times) of everything that everyone else has and to be honest had the funniest E3 presentations in history. I always look forward to a Sony presser because I always know there is going to be a moment in it that will be made into a famous meme.

Playstation is iconic because it&#39s been through everything and those who have stuck by it from the beginning know that better than anyone.

squibbfire
squibbfire
1 year ago

Yes..their Controller is iconic..being the first mega successful CD run console is iconic. Metal Gear Solid is iconic god of war resident evil…final fantasy…its hard to compare since nintendo was first

Underdog15
Underdog15
1 year ago

The better question to answer what this article is talking about is to ask them to name a video game system.

I bet in NA you&#39re more likely to get XBOX or Playstation than "Nintendo".

Hexen
Hexen
1 year ago

Well Nintendo was the most Iconic ever with great systems but after their last two toddler friendly systems and turning their franchises into cheap whores I view them as less iconic and relevant than Xbox.